It is common to accommodate a student on an Individual Education Plan due to a disability either intellectual or physical, by reducing her workload if that is appropriate. For example, an English teacher might require a student to answer one of two questions as thoroughly as every one else in the class. For the second question he might jot down a few words to remind him of his thoughts on a possible answer, if he had time. He will meet requirements of the assignment by thinking about both questions, but reducing the amount of writing required would accommodate his dysgraphia.
I should add that there are many other forms of accommodation. Shortening the amount of work is only one but sometimes a useful one.
Gifted students on an IEP may have the number of questions they do for math practice reduced as they do not need as many to cement the concept. Instead, the teacher may assign problems that take them farther into the concept.
You can see where this is leading. What a teacher assigns and the amount she assigns is tied in to how much work she believes is needed to learn the material. If you have read my four posts “How do you get to Carnegie Hall?” you will remember that repetition AKA practice is necessary for learning skills.
If a student is not on an IEP, does a teacher have a moral right to change the program he used his expertise, experience and professional judgement to design just to accommodate a normal student who hasn’t handed in some assignments?
Consistently not doing work is a behaviour problem and those who are best equipped to deal with them should be informed: parents, guidance counsellors, principals, vice principals. In the meantime, teachers should be allowed to get on with what they were trained to do. And that includes assessment
Do we really want our future doctor, lawyer, builder of bridges, electrician or plumber accepted to train in their professions even though they had missed parts of their math or physics or English classes? If they find zeroes discouraging, let them ask for help. If they don’t want to learn enough to ask for help, please don’t lie to the public by indicating they have actually passed a course.
- Edmonton teacher may lose job for refusing to let kids skip assignments (news.nationalpost.com)
- Helping High School Student with IEP (parentshelpingparentsiep.wordpress.com)